Langsung ke konten utama

Tribal democracy works as chaos reigns

In a heady day of noise, confusion, shouting, interminable delays and poetic speeches calling for unity and peace, Afghans yesterday enjoyed their first experience of real democracy after 23 years of war.
About 1,500 delegates revelled in a sometimes chaotic debate inside and outside the tent where the loya jirga, or tribal council, began to decide the future of their nation.
In their speeches men and women abused almost every warlord and politician in the country, often by name, for devastating Afghanistan. The warlords and ministers sitting in the front rows heard them in stony silence.
Others claimed that the Americans and other foreigners were interfering in Afghan democracy by forcing the former king, Zahir Shah, to turn down a formal post in the new administration.
"We don't want the loya jirga to be a rubber stamp," said Mohammed Daud, a Pathan delegate from Kabul. "It will be hypocritical for the West to send soldiers to help democracy and then interfere when the democratic process starts."
At times speakers acted like football hooligans, at other times there was spell-binding oratory. But there always appeared to be some order behind the chaos.
Still some delegates were furious at the lack of free votes and 60 to 70 walked out of the 1,600-member meeting.

Hamid Karzai, the US-backed leader of the interim administration and likely president, added to the confusion after the opening ceremony on Tuesday when he told some journalists that he already had the job in the bag.

"It is finished," he said. "The assembly has voted for me." A spokesman for Mr Karzai said yesterday the leader had made "a mistake".

The council failed to deal with its first main business, the election of a chairman.

The vote which had still not taken place by nightfall, is important because it could also help to decide whether Mr Karzai will have to face opponents for the role of president, to lead the country for the next two years.

The two main candidates are the acting chairman, Ismail Qasimyar, and Azizullah Wassafi, who is loyal to Zahir Shah.

If Mr Wassafi, who is also opposed to Mr Karzai, wins, it will encourage others to challenge for the presidency.

Outside the gates of the loya jirga, a jeep carrying four armed bodyguards of Wali Massoud, the brother of the assassinated Gen Ahmad Shah Massoud, was stopped by German troops of the International Security Assistance Force who forcibly disarmed them.

Gen Sayaf Khalil said the foreign troops over-reacted, pointing weapons at the bodyguards' heads. But Wali Massoud said it was a minor incident.

Col Helen Wildman, an ISAF spokesman, said at one point a man aimed his rifle at the Germans before he was disarmed.

Later, German troops accidentally fired machineguns at an Afghan television truck causing panic at a nearby hotel. No one was hurt.

Source: http://www.telegraph.co.uk 

Komentar

Postingan populer dari blog ini

Tribal Society + Democracy = ?

How (if at all) will tribal cultures and societies come to incorporate democratic ideals? The self-immolation of a man in Tunisia has literally sent dominoes falling across the Arab world. People are getting a taste of individual liberty and freedom that has long been denied. Obviously, the road forward will not be smooth. From where I sit in the west, there appears to be an inherent conflict between tribal society/culture and elements of democracy like majority rule and protection of minority rights. Is this conflict actually different from (less than?) what I may be seeing through my western eyes? Are there historical examples we can examine for how tribal societies morphed into more democratic ones? While no one can predict the future, what might historians say - fifty years from now - about how this drive for liberty and freedom played out? *** All European societies have tribal origins, if you go back far enough in the historical record. But who remember...

West Papua: Independence movement defies repression

West Papua: Independence movement defies repression By Ash Pemberton Rally for West Papuan independence in Port Vila, Vanuatu, March 5. Vanuatu will officially sponsor the case of West Papua in the International Court of Justice. Photo: Asia-pacific-action.org Indonesian military forces have stepped up their campaign of repression in West Papua in recent months. But leaders of the Free Papua Movement (OPM) continue to defy Indonesian demands to surrender. The campaign for West Papuan independence has been amplified by the continuing repression and lack of improvement of living standards under the current “special autonomy” system. An eyewitness report from West Papua Media Announcements (WPMA) posted on Pacific.scoop.co.nz on June 16 described a large military mobilisation in the mountainous Puncak Jaya region in central West Papua. The report said the Indonesian military and the paramilitary Mobile Brigade (Brimob) have engaged in a campaign of harassment and intimidation ...

The Six Nations: Oldest Living Participatory Democracy on Earth

The people of the Six Nations, also known by the French term, Iroquois [ 1 ] Confederacy, call themselves the Hau de no sau nee (ho dee noe sho nee) meaning People Building a Long House. Located in the northeastern region of North America, originally the Six Nations was five and included the Mohawks, Oneidas, Onondagas, Cayugas, and Senecas. The sixth nation, the Tuscaroras, migrated into Iroquois country in the early eighteenth century. Together these peoples comprise the oldest living participatory democracy on earth. Their story, and governance truly based on the consent of the governed, contains a great deal of life-promoting intelligence for those of us not familiar with this area of American history. The original United States representative democracy, fashioned by such central authors as Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson, drew much inspiration from this confederacy of nations. In our present day, we can benefit immensely, in our quest to establish anew a ...